You might be surprised to know that scrapple was known in Massachusetts at least as far back as the mid-19th century. So, let's take a look at that early history, as well as see some of the recipes that were presented in these early Massachusetts newspapers. Maybe some of your Massachusetts ancestors even made their own scrapple.
The earliest Massachusetts newspaper reference I found to scrapple was from 1848. The
Vox Populi, December 29, 1848, briefly noted, "
With a pretty assortment of scrapple, butter and other greasy delicacies, Sylvanus Wilson came from his rural home in Chester county, and arrived in this virtuous city of Philadelphia on yesterday morning." This only referenced scrapple in Pennsylvania, but may hav intrigued readers in Massachusetts who wanted to know what it might be.
The
Hampshire Gazette & Northampton Courier, August 19, 1862, presented an article on
Rearing and Fattening Hogs by
Gates Henry of Pennsylvania. It mentioned, "
The way in which to realize the most money out of the hog meat is to cut every available scrap into sausage meat, and boil the rest into scrapple (curing only the hams), and selling it while fresh, and the sooner the better, as both sausage and scrapple command a higher price early in the winter than at any other season." Again, this is only a reference to Pennsylvania, although it's interesting to see that its price depended on the season.
The
Massachusetts Ploughman, December 26, 1863, also noted a Pennsylvania article on killing and cutting up hogs. The article stated that in cutting up a pig's head, "
skin the snout--and take off the flesh for scrapple and throw the nasal organs away."
The first article mentioning that scrapple was available in Massachusetts was from 1864. The
Salem Register, January 25, 1864, printed an advertisement for the Essex Market, which sold a variety of meats and vegetables, including "
Scrapple" which is "
partially cooked and a portion of the fat extracted." Who was eating scrapple at that time? Were they eating it for breakfast?
A scrapple recipe! The
New England Farmer, March 31, 1866, presented the first scrapple recipe in a Massachusetts newspaper. It was in a letter submitted from a reader in Vermont, who seemed familiar with Pennsylvania. The reader begins, "
But I wonder if she ever heard of anything called Scrapple. If not, I conclude she is not a Pennsylvanian." For the recipe, it states, "
I take the upper half of a hog's head, upper joints of the legs, and the bloody pieces about the neck where the hog is struck, and all the rinds that come off the meat, and boil them until I can remove the bones easily."
The meat will eventually be seasoned with salt, pepper and sage. Later, you will add 2 handfuls of sifted wheat flour and 1 handful of Indian meal. Once done, it's placed into tin pans to cool, and 24 hours later, you can cut it into half-inch slices and fry it up. "It is very handy for breakfast these cold mornings..."
There was another recipe in the
Springfield Daily Republican, January 30, 1872, requiring a pig's head for the meat. The meat was to be seasoned with pepper, salt, thyme, sage, and sweet marjoram, different from the prior recipe. Then, it called for equal parts of buckwheat and corn meal, a proportion different from the prior recipe too. The cost to make this recipe was said to be 50 cents, but it would provide a family of five enough food for breakfast for an entire week.
A week later, the Springfield Daily Republican, February 8, 1872, discussed a man in New York talking about the amount he paid for food each week. His wife allotted 45 cents for breakfast, and the man stated, "Could I do it for less eating scrapple? I know what it is; it's an old Pennsylvania dish, and my wife's folks come from Bucks county. Don't think we would like it every day of the week." He also noted that one of his daughters is delicate so "must not eat greasy food."
The Boston Semi-Weekly Advertiser, February 9, 1872, referenced an article in the New York Times which gave advice on managing a limited income, and it noted that scrapple was a cheap dish.
The
Recorder, February 25, 1878, provided another scrapple recipe, similar in several ways to the previous recipe from the
Springfield Daily Republican, January 30, 1872. The Recorder recipe also mentions using a fresh pig’s head, but also "other cuttings of pork." The seasonings for the meat are the same, but it's thickened only with yellow Indian-meal (cornmeal), and no flour.
Scrapple in the Arctic? The New England Farmer, April 5, 1884, reported on the outfitting of the Greely Relief Expedition to the Arctic. Also known as the Lady Franklin Bay Expedition, its purpose was to establish a meteorological-observation station. They needed to pack food supplies for 140 men for 2 years, 60 dogs and their drivers. Their cargo included 2000 pounds of Philadelphia scrapple, and it was said, “Scrapple is a hash of meat well boiled and mixed properly with corn meal and buckwheat flour.”
The
Boston Evening Transcript, April 19, 1884, provided the above recipe for
Corned Beef Scrapple, maybe because of the strong Irish population of the area. The recipe called for a four-pound piece of corned beef, which would later be mixed with a cup of hominy grits and two cups of yellow corn-meal, as well as seasonings of black pepper and sage. This scrapple recipe might appeal to people who are too squeamish to eat scrapple made from pig's heads or offal.
Scrapple and the holidays! The
Boston Globe, November 11, 1885, in an article on
Good Things for Thanksgiving, noted, "
Scrapple from Philadelphia is ten cents a pound." And the
Boston Globe, December 19, 1886, presented suggested menus for Christmas week dinners and one of those supper menus included
Fried Scrapple, Stewed Prunes and Bread.
The
Springfield Daily Republican, December 1, 1890, presented a scrapple recipe from
Good Housekeeping magazine. Again, a pig's head, without the brains, was used, although noting the brains "
make an excellent entree." About three cupfuls of yellow meal would be added to it, and seasoned with salt, red and black pepper, powdered thyme, and sage. It was also stated, "
This is a winter dish and especially goof with buckwheat cakes."
Another recipe. The
New England Farmer, January 2, 1892, provided its own recipe for scrapple, calling for pig's feet, ears, and the upper part of the head. It would be seasoned with only salt and pepper, and sifted corn meal would be added as well, until it became a mush.
The
Boston Globe, August 27, 1893, provided this scrapple recipe, similar to some of the prior ones.
The
Standard Times, November 15, 1894, printed an ad for
E.C. Brownell & Co., located in New Bedford, which indicated they sold scrapple.
A beef scrapple recipe! The
Boston Globe, January 12, 1895, provided this alternative scrapple recipe, which used a beef brisket. It required the addition of sweet marjoram, thyme, parsley, chopped celery tops, and two onions. It also asked for yellow Indian meal, and no type of flour.
The Evening Herald, August 13, 1895, presented an amusing item, which probably wasn't actually true, about scrapple at Philadelphia hotels. "Scrapple and fried mush are the principal breakfast dishes in Philadelphia. The hotels print these two dishes in black type at the head of their bills of fare. If you pass them over and order something else, the waiter looks at you with astonishment. Then he brings you as little as he can of the dishes you order and extra large portions of scrapple and fried mush besides. He stands at your elbow and watches you eat. If you don't tackle the scrapple and mush at once, he will push the other dishes out of your way."
The
Boston Globe, April 18, 1896, printed a
recipe for
Philadelphia Scrapple, calling for 6 pounds of pork (of unspecified type) and 4 pounds of beef liver. The seasonings included sage (or mixed herbs if preferred), black pepper, cayenne pepper and salt. It would also be thickened with Indian meal, without any flour.
Another beef scrapple recipe. The
Boston Morning Journal, October 29, 1896, provided a recipe for beef scrapple, claiming it is "
more healthful than when made from pork."
The Boston Evening Transcript, November 20, 1896, briefly mentioned that Philadelphia scrapple "has now become a feature of the most fashionable cafes in New York." Such a humble dish making its appearance in such fashionable spots.
The
Springfield Daily Republican, January 29, 1897, presented an ad for State-Street Market Co., noting that it sold "
Philadelphia Scrapple. Something new."
The
Boston Evening Transcript, February 20, 1897, offered another recipe for scrapple, stating the dish is made "
from pig's head or nice bits of lean fresh pork, the tongue, and parts of the liver." It was to be seasoned with salt, pepper and herbs. Although it called for yellow Indian meal, it noted some people referred a mix of meal and buckwheat flour.
The Worcester Daily Spy, April 15, 1897, offered its own take on a scrapple recipe.
Another amusing article. The Boston Evening Transcript, September 28, 1897, published an article titled, "Pennsylvania's Depraved Diet." It noted, "Sausage is so suspiciously made from doubtful parts of pork meat as to be shunned by many. The parts too poor for sausage--literally scraps--these, with a liberal admixture of corn-meal, the whole being boiled to homogeneity and cooled in pans, constitute scrapple." It continued, "Scrapple would seem to be an evolution or hard times and frugality...for every gustatory law is apparently violated in scrapple."
And one more scrapple recipe as in the
North Adams Transcript, May 28, 1898.
And we finish with a deadly scrapple! The Boston Globe, February 3, 1899, reported that, "Ptomaine poisoning caused by eating scrapple has just killed a man in Philadelphia, but any true Philadelphian will brave death cheerfully rather than give scrapple up."
This appears to have actually happened. The Harrisburg Telegraph (PN), February 1, 1899, reported that Charles H. Taylor, age 59, died, apparently from ptomaine poisoning, "the result of impure meat used in the manufacture of scrapple, which article of food he ate for breakfast." This article was repeated in a number of other Pennsylvania newspapers.
So, we have seen some of the history of scrapple in Massachusetts during the 19th century. I've provided a number of early recipes, which vary to one degree or another, and also showed that it was commercially available at different times. Today, it's rare to find scrapple in Massachusetts on restaurant menus or at grocery stores.
********************
Peter Bryant's* Scrapple Recipe: Peter generously shared his recipe with me, allowing me to post it on my blog. His recipe has options so you can make a more traditional version, or Peter's variation (which might appeal more to those who are squeamish about using offal). I enjoyed the scrapple prepared using his variation, and it's certainly a dish that many people would enjoy if they were willing to taste it.
Ingredients
2 pounds of pork shoulder
1/2 pound of pork liver (see substitution below)
3 quarts of stock (from cooking, see below)
1/4 cup of sage
1/4 cup of salt (I substitute about a quarter of this with MSG)
1/4 cup of black pepper (I substitute half of this with Old Bay seasoning)
1 pound of corn meal
12 ounces of flour (substitute corn flour or buckwheat for gluten free).
Directions
Cook the pork shoulder in about 3 quarts of water. Bone-in is preferred for flavor. Go a little heavier to account for bone weight. I use an Instapot, high pressure for 45 minutes.
If you are using liver, put this in there as well. Liver is traditional and I don't mind it. However, I prefer to substitute in 1/4 pound of sausage and 1/4 pound of thick cut bacon. Fry that up and set aside.
Remove the meat from the stock. Strain the stock but save it. Put 3 quarts of that into a pot along with spices and set to boil.
Shred the pork and fine chop liver (or the bacon and sausage).
Once the water is boiling, carefully whisk in the grains and return to a boil (keep stirring).
Once it is boiling, mix in your meats.
Turn off the heat and put into pans for cooling. I use mini loaf pans as I'm the only one in my house that eats scrapple.
Once it's cool enough, cover and put in the refrigerator over night. You can vaccu-seal what you don’t eat and freeze it for later.

*Peter Bryant is an engineer, game designer, artist, and food enthusiast. You can find him and his work on Instagram @peterbbryant or at solariangames.com